01-05-2013, 07:02 PM
This thread got me thinking so I thought I would do a full thread on it
https://manutdpeople.com/Thread-1999-versus-2013
I couldn't find ratings on United's team from 1999 so I went for a comparison with the 2008 team that won the Champions League.
Goalkeepers
2008 - Edwin Van Der Sar - Rating 85
2013 - David de Gea - Rating 81
Defenders
2008 - G. Neville - Rating 80
2008 - R. Ferdinand - Rating 88
2008 - N. Vidic - Rating 85
2008 - P. Evra - Rating 78
2013 - Rafael - Rating 78
2013 - R. Ferdinand - Rating 83
2013 - N. Vidić - Rating 87
2013 - P. Evra - Rating -82
Midfielders
2008 - C. Ronaldo - Rating 91
2008 - P. Scholes - Rating 85
2008 - O. Hargreaves - Rating - 81
2008 - R. Giggs - Rating 86
2013 - A. Valencia - Rating 83
2013 - P. Jones - Rating 77
2013 - R. Giggs - Rating 80
2013 - S. Kagawa - Rating 83
Forwards
2008 - W. Rooney - Rating 90
2008 - C. Tevez - Rating 88
2013 - W. Rooney - Rating 87
2013 - R. Van Persie - Rating 89
Do you agree with these ratings? I took them all from the PS3 edition of FIFA 13 and FIFA 08.
https://manutdpeople.com/Thread-1999-versus-2013
I couldn't find ratings on United's team from 1999 so I went for a comparison with the 2008 team that won the Champions League.
Goalkeepers
2008 - Edwin Van Der Sar - Rating 85
2013 - David de Gea - Rating 81
Defenders
2008 - G. Neville - Rating 80
2008 - R. Ferdinand - Rating 88
2008 - N. Vidic - Rating 85
2008 - P. Evra - Rating 78
2013 - Rafael - Rating 78
2013 - R. Ferdinand - Rating 83
2013 - N. Vidić - Rating 87
2013 - P. Evra - Rating -82
Midfielders
2008 - C. Ronaldo - Rating 91
2008 - P. Scholes - Rating 85
2008 - O. Hargreaves - Rating - 81
2008 - R. Giggs - Rating 86
2013 - A. Valencia - Rating 83
2013 - P. Jones - Rating 77
2013 - R. Giggs - Rating 80
2013 - S. Kagawa - Rating 83
Forwards
2008 - W. Rooney - Rating 90
2008 - C. Tevez - Rating 88
2013 - W. Rooney - Rating 87
2013 - R. Van Persie - Rating 89
Do you agree with these ratings? I took them all from the PS3 edition of FIFA 13 and FIFA 08.